Turning around a DTC brand with a 30% drop in YoY Sales with Retention Marketing

Turning around a DTC brand with a 30% drop in YoY Sales with Retention Marketing

A recent client recently approached us in a panic, with Q2 sales down in 2025 over 16% compared to the previous year. Here’s an overview of how this impacted retention marketing efforts, as well as the 8-step strategy our team has put together to get their business back on track.

The Data Behind the Drop in Revenue

First, a bit of context about this brand:

They sell designer handbags, exclusively direct to consumer.

META is their obvious go-to acquisition channel, and they were recently impacted badly by the Trump Tariffs compressing margins in their business and causing instability.

This led to them reigning back on discounting the last quarter, a key promotional driver of revenue over their retention channels such as email and SMS.

In addition to this, we also seen the following email-specific statistics which were troubling:

  • Flow revenue down over 28% YoY
  • Campaign revenue down by 17.4%
  • Email flow revenue per recipient down 23.7%

A quick surface-level analysis would lead you to believe that our strategy was failing.

However, we dug deeper.

Upon further investigation, we saw that the brand has acquired 30.2% LESS customers in Q2 versus 2024’s numbers!

Given that their purchase latency is quite long (the product is hardly consumable by nature), we took it upon ourselves to devise a strategy that could cover the shortfall in revenue whilst the acquisition team stabilised proceedings.

The 8-step strategy we created

1: Change promotional strategy

The brand had moved too far away from the drivers of campaign revenue over email.

While margins are tighter before, we realised that campaign performance will be sluggish without any incentives for this particular brand.

We are introducing incentives such as GWP, cost-saving bundles, gifting packages, and limited edition drops more heavily into future emails.

Yes, it’ll require more resourcing, but this is the way to salvage campaign performance and drive more returning customer revenue.

2: Increase Sending Frequency

While this brand already sends with a modest cadence of 2-3 times per week, we have decided to increase this until acquisition in the business stabilises to see if it can improve cashflow.

This isn’t a long-term solution, but it can help in the short-term.

3: Add high-intent retargeting

One of the ways we’ll be increasing frequency without adversely impacting deliverability is by adding high-intent retargeting into the mix.

This is a lesson from Monster Email Marketing, whereby we target people who clicked on emails & SMS but didn’t convert within 24 hours.

Here’s what it looks like in practice:

Example of a high-intent retargeting email flow
Example of a high-intent retargeting email flow

4: Expand segmentation net

Whilst the majority of our targeting focused on 90-day engaged email recipients, we’ve decided to go more broad, expanding the net occasionally to target people as wide as last having engaged 365 days ago.

This will be done carefully in order to protect deliverability, but we must squeeze the sponge in order to recover lost revenue, even if it’s just a temporary measure.

5: Double down on Direct Mail Reactivations

Unfortunately, a bi-product of increasing sending frequency, we will be churning email subscribers more quickly.

We’ve now convinced this brand to double down on incremental testing of winback campaigns with Direct Mail, as well as targeting existing customers disengaged with email.

The criteria for these will expand to broader segments once we validate incremental returns.

6: Collect UGC from VIPs to repurpose to Ad Creatives

It’s time to think outside the box more for this brand and support them in addressing the root cause of the issue, and email is one of the best channels to help them achieve this.

Take a look at some powerful ways they can generate UGC from their existing customers over email:

Example of an email requesting user-generated content from VIP customers

7. Collect more Zero-Party Data & Analyse Commonalities

Ask customers better questions on the pop-ups, and then conduct a Lifetime Value analysis on shared attributes in order to strengthen front-end conversion efforts and acquisition campaign efficiency.

8: Deploy Qualitative Research to customers who don’t convert

The same logic as the previous step applies.

This one is particularly important given that flow RPR is down YoY, suggesting a quality of audience issue.

Harnessing these insights on autopilot and then syncing them back to the acquisition team is a crucial way to improve overall sales.

More on this strategy can be found here.

Conclusion

While the top 5 strategies are revenue drivers we have control over, the latter 3 are focused around holistic brand performance.

Because as you can see from this article, the impact of email tends to be downstream of overall acquisition performance in the business.

And the levers that we’re able to pull to mitigate this, are at best sometimes temporary measures designed to temporarily bolster cashflow.

While the top 5 steps will work effectively, the timeframe they will work on isn’t infinite. Eventually, we have to solve the root cause as a team, and that’s where the bottom 3 strategies are critical.

‍

FAQ

Why does a DTC brand's email and SMS revenue drop even though it may not be due to a retention failure?

Let's answer this question based on the above blog - flow revenue was down over 28% YoY, campaign revenue down 17.4%, and flow revenue per recipient down 23.7%, numbers that looked like retention was failing. But digging deeper showed the brand had acquired 30.2% fewer customers in Q2 versus 2024, made worse by pulling back on discounting after Trump Tariffs compressed margins. Given how long the purchase latency is for designer handbags, that acquisition shortfall couldn't be plugged by retention channels alone.

What are the first 5 tactical steps in the retention plan?

Reintroducing promotional incentives like gift-with-purchase, cost-saving bundles, gifting packages and limited-edition drops into campaigns. Temporarily increasing sending frequency beyond the brand's usual 2 to 3 times a week. Adding high-intent retargeting that targets people who clicked an email or SMS but didn't convert within 24 hours. Expanding the segmentation net from a 90-day engaged window out to 365 days, done carefully to protect deliverability. And doubling down on Direct Mail winback campaigns for customers who've become disengaged with email.

Why are these 5 tactical steps described as temporary measures rather than a fix?

Because they're revenue levers the retention team can control directly, but they don't address why acquisition slowed down in the first place. These moves can bolster cashflow in the short term, but the timeframe they work on isn't infinite. Eventually the root cause, which sits upstream in acquisition, has to be solved as a team.

What are the 3 strategic steps aimed at the root cause?

Collecting user-generated content from VIP customers over email to repurpose into ad creatives. Asking better questions on pop-ups and running a lifetime value analysis on shared customer attributes to sharpen front-end conversion and acquisition efficiency. And deploying qualitative research to customers who don't convert, since flow revenue per recipient being down YoY points to an audience quality issue, not just an engagement one.

How does this case study reflect the idea that retention is downstream of acquisition?

The brand's retention numbers looked broken on the surface, but the actual problem was fewer new customers entering the file. Email and SMS can only monetise the customers acquisition brings in, so when acquisition slows, flow and campaign revenue drop with it even if the retention programme itself hasn't changed. Sending more and incentivising harder only buys time. The real fix happens at the acquisition level, with retention's role being to feed insights back upstream through UGC, zero-party data and qualitative research.

‍

SHARE
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Email

Keep on Reading

State of the DTC Retention Agency: 2025 Report

by
Adam Kitchen

How to Use Klaviyo's Predictive Analytics: The Expected Date of Next Order Flow

by
Andrew Langhorn

Email Marketing Deliverability Bible for eCommerce Stores | UPDATED 2026

by
Adam Kitchen with Nick Koreck
Monster head
BOOK A DISCOVERY CALL
‍